AFC MP Sheila Holder tonight during the 2011 Budget debate proposed that the names of 17000 old age pensioners be removed from the pensioners register since according to her these persons were either deceased or non-existent. When challenged by the speaker and PPP MPs to produce evidence Holder was unable to do so. She had earlier based her suggestion on the findings of a so-called survey done by her. Holder was forced to apologise for what was termed her "indecent proposal" by other members of the house. And up to this point was unable to supply other MPs with evidence of her survey/investigation.